Hundley always looked OK playing against vanilla defenses. So his performance in preseason has little bearing for the season. Has he turned the corner, I don't know

I was sold on Hundley after last season. After all, if Rodgers isn't playing, the season is effectively over and GBs competing for a better draft slot. Hundley is the man for that job, no doubt about it.

Kizer is 22 years old - Hundley - 25. Kizer was playing as starting QB for bad team out of college. Hundley had 2 full seasons behind Aaron and showed nothing when he called to play for Packers. Do you remember that game against Ravens last season? After that game he needed to be cut immediately!

If Hundley's 1st option is taken by defense, he runs around like chicken w/o head. He has no vision and he has no progression when he leads the offense. These 2 things you can not coach!

So, forget Hundley. If only Packers were smarter and placed Tysom Hill on QB 2 place last season, we would have very good back up QB today!

I have an idea, cut them both. Save the bit of money, free up a roster spot and start again perhaps later. The backups on other teams look better than our backups. If Aaron goes down the team is toast anyway. All the Packers need is one QB starter and a PS player to share reps. And if we have a dominant defense and good running game then having one or two less backup QB’s is just fine

Kizer won the job. The better arm always wins. We saw Hill leave and look what Happened. Kizer should be the back-up.

I will say Hundley looks a lot better this preseason. Whether thats due to him improving or him playing against weaker opponents and not being schemed against, I don't know.

I still see his tendency's to hold the ball but he has been better overall.

What? No grumbly-old-man comments about gum chewing yet?

I would be shopping Hundley hard for a backup OT. Kizer is new, 22 years old and played behind terrible blocking this preseason.

Resources need to be allocated to protecting Rogers vs who is going to carry a clipboard on the sidelines.

“Hesitation” Hundley always looks good in August. But whoever sticks will not be a starter anyway. I say plan for the future, cut both if need be. Trade for someone else or plan for a future draft pick. Start over. Sure, a trade would be nice but nobody will trade a good player for him anyway. Let it go.

He's definitely performed better than the other backups this preseason.

Being the best of the backups means nothing if he has no future. None of them is the future. We would probably be better off with a well traveled veteran to fill in this year. If we want a backup QB for the future, he is not on the roster now.

The Packer press always falls in love with Mr. August around this time of year. Unfortunately, so do the Packer coaches. They all pretend that he’s not going to suck when he goes against NFL starters even though they’ve seen it with their own eyes time after time.

I didn't see enough pre-season to judge but the reviews on Hundley seem very mixed. Boyle is a surprise. He had some very nice deep passes in the first game and even short ones were crisp. Kizer - just something wrong here.

I just don't believe Hundley could change that much after last season's showing. Will new management keep last year's bad decision going? Fool me once....

McTubby always will keep the player that is a good guy even though his play is not up to par. Barclay anyone? The fact that Kizer has not get the chance to play with the number 2s meaning the nice guy Hunley who shows off all kinds of skills during preseason then plays worse at home then on the road? Hunley and his gum chewing like a cow needs to go!

If they waste a roster spot with with one of these guys they're crazy. Pick one and develop Boyle on the practice squad.

It doesn't matter who won the job. No way gute is going to cut Kizer after trading for him. The only question is if they keep both Hundley and Kizer.

Dump Hundley and send Boyle to the PS. simple as that.

Am I all warm and fuzzy about Hundley backing up Rodgers? Yes I am.

Again, people forget what a horrible team surrounded Hundley last season. Lousy running game, banged-up line, slow receivers, terrible tight ends, and a complete sieve for a defense forcing Hundley to play desperate. That mess got Aaron killed.

I also like Kizer a lot, and firmly believe he is the future backing up Rodgers--and he's actually progressing nicely (I laugh when people hold last Friday's debacle against him).

Folks, WE ARE LOADED at backup QB, and that's a good thing. Keep all 3, then trade Hundley when a team gets desperate due to injuries.

Of all the positions on this team, I worry least about QB.

Those ARE bad numbers.

The Hundley truthers are interesting. For some reason everything the guy put on film last year does not exist. Sorry you can't burn the tape. These same folks think "we'll just trade him for a pick later." There has to be a market for a player to trade said player for a pick. Hundley has no trade value because there is no market for him people! I hope he is not on the 53.

My concern is keeping 3 QBs and burning a roster spot that could be used for a more needed player. I believe Hundley is slightly better than Kizer at this point, but I don't think either one of them will win a string of games for the Packers if AR goes down.

I believe Hundley has hit his ceiling and that Kizer has more upside. By all reports, Kizer has a better arm and less understanding of the Packer system which means he has more room for growth. Kizer also has two more years on his rookie contract. It is time to move on from the Hundley experiment.

I simply have seen no improvement in Hundley from last year. He has happy feet in the pocket. He panics and takes off if his primary receiver is covered. His pocket presence and ability to read the field is terrible.

And most of his completions will be the short instant read quick hitter because he does not have the patience to let a receiver clear downfield during his route.

And he takes A LOT of sacks...which are drive killers and game changers.

This was how he played last year.

And this was how the scouts evaluated his play in college prior to his draft.

And he will be gone next year.

He hasn't outplayed Kizer by much, if at all.

Kizer at least shows pocket presence and ability to read and find an open receiver. He's not exactly "the guy" to back up Aaron yet either. But at least he will continue to learn and grow this year, next year, and the year after in Green Bay.

Unless is a team is very desperate they are not going to trade for Hundley. The game still moves too fast for him during the regular season. Think about who on the Packers roster or which draft pick you would trade for Hundley if the Packers became desperate enough for a QB.

Kizer is not great either but he has more upside than Hundley and he may develop into a solid backup. It looks like we're going to keep both Hundley and Kizer which, to me, results in a wasted spot on the 53.

It looks like we're stuck with Hundley until 2019 when we can chuck him, keep Kizer and maybe draft a legit QB for the backup role longer term.

At this point, Hundley or Kizer, we're lost if AR goes down again. Thanks, Since '61

Meh, I dont feel he stood out at all, I thought Kizer had more pocket awareness, and just needed to get more comfortable in the system, Hundley looked about the same as he did last season, no better no worse. IMO.
Go Pack!

Has Hundley slightly outplayed Kizer? Maybe. The one thing someone pointed out on one of the other blogs is that Hundley has had the benefit of the better starters AND the SCRIPTED plays. When he doesn't have to make a decision he plays fine which is why he looks good early. To me he still has that "deer in the headlights" look later in the game and still hesitates, then immediately thinks of running. I just think his in game "processor" is too slow for the NFL game. I don't know what Gute is going to do, but Kizer is the future and Hundley definitely is not (Plus, I just can't stand that cow-like gum chewing. Simply drives me nuts to look at him during the game). I hope that Kizer is able to START this week. I'd like to see how he does with the scripted plays and better starters.

‘Happyfeet’ Hundley is not going to change.
Both Kizer and Boyle have far better arms.

If ARod is hurt for more than a game or two, the season is over anyway. So why not just roll with Kizer and see what he can develop into? Give Hundley's roster spot to another developmental prospect where we need some depth. OT, OLB, CB, ILB come to mind.

Bearmeat, you are on the money. I say, why throw good money after bad? If Hundley gets cut, I am pretty sure no one else will pick him up. So he is available without losing a spot for a better player. Do we really NEED three QB’s? I don’t think so. And who cares if somebody might pick up a waved player that would not play anyway?

How many times have we seen Hundley have great showings in the preseason? I understand that he looks a bit better this go around, but I think we understand his limitations after 9 games in the “real” NFL... this is definitely a tough one, but I think we’ve already seen the ceiling from someone who has spent over three years in the system.

back up QB is a moot point......simply put....no Rodgers....no championship......end of story......

There are times people writing articles here really seem to have the interests and judgment of bear fans.

Jay and BH can coexist on a team and for fans; not Arod and BH. Something terrible wrong with perceptions of people who think BH out played Kizer

BH has the fact that MM ran his mouth about BH last year and fell on his tongue. Does MM admit a mistake after only a year?

lets see special teams coaches, capers, Randall and so many other say no....no you get 3 or 4 years to admit a mistake

If BH is our backup QB, we don’t have a backup QB

Has Hundley REALLY earned the backup QB job? I think not and here's why...

1. Hundley is in his fourth year in this offense. In his rookie preseason and preseason nos. 3-4, he has looked good. He should look better each preseason but, IMO, maintains his performance level. Kizer is in his fourth (fifth?) month. This is a poor comparison.

2. Hundley played nine regular season games last year and showed eratic play. Kizer started 15 games as a rookie and, as almost all rookies do, he played erratically. But, during the second half of his season in Cleveland, his numbers did improve. His improvement, on paper, is better than Hundley's alleged improvement.

3. Kizer can throw the ball better than Hundley. There's no argument there.

I have no doubt Hundley should be released. He has no trade value. Kizer has a little more but not much. But, MM is still the HC. This fact, in and of itself, scares me into believing Hundley will be the #2 QB.

Going into the 2017 season GB thought they had a starting-caliber backup in Hundley. Now? Who knows. But I feel like in 2017 too much time was spent trying to make Hundley play ARs offense, instead of playing to his strengths. The TB game is a great testament to that, as the offense didn't really come alive until they really started committing to zone reads and feeding the ball to Aaron Jones. (I was totally wrong w this statement and am not deleting it to admit I was totally wrong. Thought it was Jones, not Williams, that came alive at the end if the game).

With AR still not having a long-term contract, I think the Packers need a backup QB that could be a legitimate bridge to the next franchise QB if needed. I don't think either of the backups are that guy today, but Kizer probably has more upside if you want the current QB2 to be on the team 1-3 tears from now.

Hundley hasn’t earned anything. He still looks like he’s playing college ball. He stepped up in the pocket maybe three times in three games. He bails out quickly and can’t throw accurately because he has no foot or hip moves. He’s quick like a scared bunny. Kizer isn’t any better. The Packers are not “loaded” at quarterback. Is Matt Flynn available? I don’t see what McCarthy sees in Hundley.

Can Hundley throw for 3-4 td’s a game? Can he make an accurate corner of the end zone throw? He’s a dump off to the back/short sideline thrower. That won’t win any games, especially with a suspect defense and a spotty offensive line and a running game that is still untested.

Unfortunately Hundley has a resume. We saw last year what he can do. I didn't see any improvement so far. Kizer isn't any better. Flip a coin and wait for someone else to be available, possibly Bridgewater.

Trade both Hundley and Kizer and find a good vet who still has a couple of years left.

That gives you at least a 50/50 chance in the worst scenario.

But, If Aaron goes down the first game - season over.