AG, no question about it.

Jim Taylor
Paul Horning
Ahman Green
John Brockington

Jim Taylor.

Ahman Green without a doubt. Strength, speed, elusiveness. He was the total package. He could get you the 3 yards when you needed it (which is why Mike Sherman is the man to blame for 4th and 26....should have run and never punted), or he could hit the home run from anywhere on the field.

I'm just waiting for the zombie apocalypse so the corpse of Johnny "Blood" McNally can climb out of his coffin and desecrate the modern NFL like he did the Dayton Triangles in 1929.

Ahman Green. My favorite RB to wear Green and Gold that I have seen.

Meeting him a few weeks ago and getting his autograph was pretty cool too.

don't forget Dorsey Levens. even though he was a fullback I liked William Henderson great set of mitts

Samkon Gado. Obviously...

A different era, but Hornung could run, receive, block, and do it all at a high level. Pretty good kicker, too, which saved a roster spot. Hard to beat all that.

It has to be Ahman Green. The other guys from the Lombardi era can't compare athletically to this era of football. It's awesome history but it's not the same game.

Green would translate immediately to the open game. D would have to play run first - no more 6 man boxes/2 deep shells.

My lifetime.

Taylor
Hornung
Brockington
Green

But with this team, Hornung, the versatility and play possibilties would be ridiculous. Then again, Taylor would punish defenders and would run over teams even with last week's OL.

Clark Hinkle

Look it up.

Epic battles with Bronko Nagurski and the hated Bears.

Bone crunching is a term often used to describe his play on both offense and defense.

Ahman Green was Great, no question about that, but until he got injured I think Travis Williams was better. Sure would like to see him again!! Great Half Back, & The Best Returner of All Time.
LVT

No Eddy Lacy? Ooooooh...

I would say Hornung or Green.

Paul Hornung! He would be a prefect fit with Aaron Rodgers and MM for that matter. Paul was a great RB inside the red zone. Secondly he was an excellent receiver out of the backfield and once he caught the ball he was a great runner in space. Third, as Lombardi said, he could block like a guard, so no worries picking up the blitz and protecting Rodgers. Fourth, he could throw the option pass as well as anyone who ever played. He won the Heisman Trophy as the Notre Dame QB so throwing was no problem.

Additionally he knew everyone's assignment on the offense. Beyond all that he could kick FGs and Extra Points, punt and kickoff if necessary. In 1960 Hornung scored an NFL record 176 points in the league's final 12 game season. That is an average of 14.67 points per game. He did it scoring TDs, kicking FGs and Xtra points. The record held until broken by L. Tomlinson in a 16 game season scoring only TDs.

Hornung was durable as well, until he suffered a pinched nerve in his neck ending his career prematurely in 1966. With the current emphasis on versatility Hornung would fit perfectly in today's complex offensive schemes. I basically became a Packers fan watching him score 19 out of 37 points scored by the Packers in their 37 - 0 romp over the NY Giants in the 1961 NFL Championship game. It seemed like the only two names I heard throughout the whole game were Hornung and Nitschke. Thanks, Since '61

I have to go with Green. A little fumbilitis in his day, but he scared the hell out of people. I never saw the older era guys play, but I do remember a 99 yard drive where we ran it right down the Buccaneers throats the entire drive. They interviewed Warren Sapp afterward in the locker room, and he said "...it isn't like we were fooled, we knew where they were running, we just couldn't stop it." Imagine a world where AR only has to pass when he feels like it....

AG
Hornung
Ivery (without the torn up knees)
Levens
Taylor
Ryan Grant
(Eric Torkelson just missed the cut)

Well, if you don't equalize the eras, then it's Green. If you just use relative performance from their current era, then Jim Taylor.

Brockington was a rookie when I started watching football Every weekend. He was a 1,000 yard machine in a 14 game era with no passing attack to threaten opponents. For a few years he was the only reason to watch the Packers.

It didn't last long and by his fourth season facing 8 men in the box wore him done.

Travis Jervey. Hands down.

Heck...I forgot about Ivery. Saw more of him in college than with the Packers. If healthy, he was a HOF runner.
I grew up watching Taylor, Horning, Brockington, and Ivery. 100 percent healthy I very was the best.
imho.

I wouldn't pick a Packer RB at all (and yes, I know that was the question).

I'd pick a guy who, when he played, was the guy I couldn't take my eyes off. He transcended team. There are RBs with better stats, but none looked like him.

Barry Sanders - legend.

Man unless you go back to the Lombardi days (which football was so different then) we just haven't had any amazing running backs. Yeah Ahman was good and Levens was pretty good, but damn id kill for just one freakin AP type back!

Travis Williams only gained 1160 yds rushing in his 6 years

Amad Green was the best Brockington was good for a short time. Donny Anderson had some good years too

Finwiz, He was a Far Better Returner than a RB. I was 20 in his Rookie season. He was so Dynamic, as a Kick Off Return player, It just over shadowed what he did as a RB to a young guy of 20. I had never seen anyone that good prior to Travis Williams. Not to make any excuses for his 4 years of yardage with GB, If I'm not mistaken GB sort of fell off the cliff his 2ond year, & went into a 25 year free fall. That's how I remember it. You are Right, he was a Much Better Returner. He was Special to me & to a lot of GB fans that remember him.
LVT

Johnny Blood!

Over the history of the Packers organization, they have never been blessed with a Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Peterson type of running back but have been more effective in each era and growth of the franchise with unsung heroes,